Get Answers
Can unfair redundancy selection happen during consultation?
Yes, it can. In a UK redundancy process, consultation is meant to be a genuine discussion about whether redundancies are necessary and, if so, how they should be handled fairly.
If an employer has already decided who will go before consultation has properly taken place, the process may be unfair. Consultation should happen before final decisions are made, not after them.
What consultation is supposed to do
Consultation gives employees a chance to understand the reasons for redundancy and comment on the proposed selection method. It should allow people to challenge scoring, suggest alternatives, and raise concerns about discrimination or mistakes.
An employer should listen with an open mind. If the consultation is only a formality, or if feedback does not affect anything, that can point to unfairness.
How unfair selection can happen
Unfair redundancy selection may happen if the employer uses inaccurate scores, applies criteria inconsistently, or relies on subjective views without evidence. It can also happen if managers already prefer certain employees to stay.
Selection can be unfair if it targets protected characteristics, such as age, sex, disability, pregnancy, maternity, race, religion, or sexual orientation. It may also be unfair if an employee is chosen for reasons linked to trade union activity or whistleblowing.
Signs the process may be unfair
Warning signs include a consultation meeting where the decision has clearly already been made. Another sign is when the employer refuses to explain the scoring or will not provide enough detail to challenge it.
It may also be problematic if the pool for selection is too small, the criteria are unclear, or the employer ignores suitable alternative roles. A lack of genuine individual consultation can also raise concerns.
What employees can do
If you think your redundancy selection is unfair, raise it during consultation as early as possible. Ask for your scores, the criteria used, and the reasons behind the decision.
You can also suggest alternatives, such as redeployment, reduced hours, or voluntary redundancy. Keep a written record of meetings, emails, and any documents shared with you.
Getting advice and challenging unfair treatment
If the employer does not address your concerns, you may want to speak to your trade union, an adviser, or an employment solicitor. This is especially important if discrimination may be involved.
Depending on the situation, you may be able to challenge the redundancy or bring a claim. Time limits can be short, so it is sensible to act quickly.
Frequently Asked Questions
Unfair redundancy selection during consultation is when an employer chooses certain employees for redundancy in a way that is unreasonable, inconsistent, discriminatory, or not properly explained while consultation is still taking place.
Unfair redundancy selection during consultation can often be identified by looking for unclear scoring, changed criteria, missed consultation meetings, bias, inconsistent treatment, or selection decisions made before consultation has genuinely finished.
Unfair redundancy selection during consultation may be unlawful if the employer uses discriminatory criteria, fails to consult properly, ignores contractual or policy rules, or treats an employee less favourably for protected reasons such as age, sex, disability, pregnancy, race, religion, or trade union activity.
An employee should ask for the selection criteria, scoring evidence, and consultation notes, raise concerns in writing, challenge any errors, and seek advice from a union representative, HR, or an employment lawyer as soon as possible.
Useful evidence includes consultation letters, meeting notes, scoring sheets, emails, policy documents, performance reviews, comparisons with other employees, and any records showing that the selection process was inconsistent or biased.
Yes, redundancy selection during consultation may be unfair if the employer had effectively decided the outcome before consultation started or before employees had a real chance to influence the decision.
Consultation should be genuine and allow employees to comment on the business case, selection criteria, alternative roles, and ways to avoid redundancies; if the employer only goes through the motions, the selection may be unfair.
Yes, unfair redundancy selection during consultation can involve discriminatory scoring if criteria directly or indirectly disadvantage a protected group, such as penalising disability-related absence or part-time working that mainly affects women.
Common mistakes include using vague criteria, failing to check scores, not training managers, applying criteria inconsistently, not consulting individually, and not considering suitable alternative employment.
Yes, an employee can and should challenge unfair redundancy selection during consultation before dismissal happens by raising objections, correcting errors, and asking the employer to reconsider the scoring or selection process.
Possible remedies include reinstatement, re-engagement, compensation, settlement agreement negotiation, or a tribunal award if the employee succeeds in an unfair dismissal or discrimination claim.
In most cases, an employee must act quickly and start the Acas Early Conciliation process within three months less one day from the effective date of termination, although discrimination claims may follow similar strict time limits.
Not always. Ordinary unfair dismissal claims usually require two years of service, but claims involving discrimination, whistleblowing, trade union rights, or certain automatically unfair reasons may not require that qualifying period.
Absence records can be used only if they are applied lawfully and fairly; it may be unfair if the employer ignores disability-related absence, maternity-related absence, or other protected absences when scoring employees.
It may be unfair if the employer fails to consider suitable alternative roles or vacancies during consultation, especially where redeployment could have avoided redundancy or reduced the impact on affected employees.
Yes, a scoring appeal can help because it gives the employee a chance to correct errors, challenge subjective judgments, and show that the selection outcome may have been unfair or unsupported by evidence.
It is usually proved by showing the employer’s process was unreasonable, inconsistent, discriminatory, or not genuinely consultative, using documents, witness evidence, and comparisons with other employees’ scores and treatment.
Yes, unfair redundancy selection during consultation can happen in a small business as well as a large one; the employer still needs to act fairly, use reasonable criteria, and consult properly with affected staff.
Fair redundancy selection during consultation uses objective criteria, genuine consultation, and consistent scoring, while unfair redundancy selection during consultation involves bias, poor process, hidden decisions, or unlawful discrimination.
An employee should only sign a settlement agreement after getting independent legal advice and carefully considering compensation, references, non-financial terms, and whether the agreement is suitable in light of the unfair redundancy selection during consultation.
Ergsy Search Results
This website offers general information and is not a substitute for professional advice.
Always seek guidance from qualified professionals.
If you have any medical concerns or need urgent help, contact a healthcare professional or emergency services immediately.
Some of this content was generated with AI assistance. We've done our best to keep it accurate, helpful, and human-friendly.
- Ergsy carefully checks the information in the videos we provide here.
- Videos shown by Youtube after a video has completed, have NOT been reviewed by ERGSY.
- To view, click the arrow in centre of video.
- Most of the videos you find here will have subtitles and/or closed captions available.
- You may need to turn these on, and choose your preferred language.
- Go to the video you'd like to watch.
- If closed captions (CC) are available, settings will be visible on the bottom right of the video player.
- To turn on Captions, click settings.
- To turn off Captions, click settings again.